Did you know that your roof could be the most important part of your home? It protects what matters to you and your family. Also we know the roof underlayment is considerably a new thing in the market, but there are already a lot of variations of it available.
So we have designed this article to assist you in selecting the best roof underlayment for your home. We will review some of the top-notch products available in the market and also provide you buying guide to make it easier for you to select the right variation. You can compare them all and choose which one you think would work best for your needs.
What Do People Like About Roof Underlayment?
The roof underlayment is not always necessary but in some areas, it’s crucial for protection. It works as a barrier to protect moisture from rain, snow, and other harsh weather conditions. The shingles on your roof work as a first line of defense but they can seal all the corners. The underlayment is necessary for perfect sealing to protect from extreme weather conditions.
You will notice that people living in the regions where ice damning or high winds are common to take the roof underlayment is a must. That’s to offer the roof the protection it needs from natural calamities.
Why do you Need Roofing Underlayment?
Roof underlayment works as the second layer of protection from severe weather and other issues. Below, we will let you know about some of the top benefits of using the roof underlayment.
Work as a moisture bar?
As we said earlier, the roofing underlayment work as an additional barrier of protection that the shingle along cannot provide. The work of shingle is to work as the first layer of defense. It reflects the sun rays, blocks precipitation, and withstand the wind. However, one issue about the shingle is they cannot seal off all the corners. Any strong wind can easily lift them off from the edge. As a result, the shingle becomes vulnerable to the wind-driven rain, which can cause tear-off or infiltration.
The roofing underlayment ensures that no moisture will get into your property or house by rain and heavy wind. Some of the roof underlayment products are also available for protecting against the snows. Roofing underlayment can also protect the roof. As time goes, the shingles become weaker and may get tear off by harsh weather conditions. As made of quality ingredients, most of the underlayment is strong enough to hold the shingles one-piece during weather conditions.
Roofing Underlayment Types
There are generally three types of roofing underlayment types. They are discussed briefly below:
Asphalt Saturated Felt
The asphalt-saturated felts are the most used underlayment used currently. The material used in the variations is similar to tar paper. However, it includes the asphalt for waterproofing substance instead of the tar paper. One of the advantages of the asphalt-saturated felt is they can add stiffness to the roof deck. It can help to improve overall durability and protect the roofing from the airborne debris, hailstone, tree branches, etc.
Non-Bitumen Synthetics
The non-bitumen synthetic underlayment is mostly used in modern roofs. It varies on different materials, including polypropylene, polyethylene, or hard-wearing plastics. The advantages of the non-bitumen synthetics are they are extraordinarily durable, waterproof, and elastic. They can also resist the growth of fungal in the roof.
Rubberized Asphalt
Rubberized asphalts are becoming a standard roof underlayment. They are almost like a sheet of rubber, though it includes the term asphalt in the name, there is little to no asphalt in the variants. You will require specialized adhesive for installation. One of the benefits of the rubberized asphalt is they are very flexible.
Such a property makes it extremely suitable for different types of weather. Depending on the product, it can arrive with various features such as waterproofing, sound-absorbing, and fiberglass reinforcement.
What Is the best roof underlayment reviews
Top-Rated Roof Underlayment: 10′ X 15′ Firestone RubberGard 60-Mil EPDM Roofing Rubber
“A top-rated roof underlayment with extraordinary sturdy construction for longevity”
Best Multi-Purpose Roof Underlayment: Tyvek Protec 120 Roof Underlayment
“Perfectly multi-purpose choice for various roofs including cedar shingles, metal roof, and asphalt shingles”
Best for DIY home Owners: Grace Select 36 in. X 195 sq. Ft. Roll Roofing
“Thin and lightweight that arrives with self-adhered properties, easy to install for DIY”
Best lightweight Roof Underlayment: Roof Protector Underlayment Roll
“Incredibly lightweight for easier installation and handling”
Best Low-Cost Roof Underlayment: MCA, Plastic String Reinforced Poly Sheeting
“Available at a reasonable price that arrives with quality properties”
Best Slip-Resistant Roof Underlayment: Grace Ice & Water Shield Roofing Underlayment
“Premier membrane composed of various waterproof materials with slip-resistant coating”
Best self-Adhering Roof Underlayment: MFM Wind & Water Seal Underlayment
“Excellent self-adhering roof underlayment solution for easy installation”
Best Roof Underlayment Reviews in 2022
The below-mentioned roof underlayment has been selected based on our in-depth research considering various aspects of the product. We thoroughly examined the construction quality, construction materials, durability, as well as the previous user impressions over the product. Check out the brief discussion about our chosen best roof underlayment from below.
Comparison Chart:
| Image | Product | Features | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
Best Roof Underlayment  | 10′ X 15′ Firestone RubberGard 60-Mil EPDM Roofing Rubber | 9.7 | Price On Amazon |
 | Tyvek Protec 120 Roof Underlayment | 9.5 | Price On Amazon |
Special Roof Underlayment  | Grace Select 36 in. X 195 sq. Ft. Roll Roofing | 9.1 | Price On Amazon |
 | Roof Protector Underlayment Roll | 8.8 | Price On Amazon |
Cheap Roof Underlayment  | MCA, Plastic String Reinforced Poly Sheeting | 8.6 | Price On Amazon |
 | Grace Ice & Water Shield Roofing Underlayment | 8.2 | Price On Amazon |
 | MFM Wind & Water Seal Underlayment | 8 | Price On Amazon |
1. 10′ X 15′ Firestone RubberGard 60-Mil EPDM Roofing Rubber – Best for Severe Weather Condition
Product Specification:
Brand: Firestone
Product Dimension: 120 x 180 x 1 inches
Weight: 60 Pounds
Size: 10×15 ftMaterial: Rubber
The 10′ X 15′ Firestone RubberGard 60-Mil EPDM Roofing Rubber is a top-rated best roof underlayment available in the market currently. One of the extraordinary things about the product is its sturdy construction. It is made of high-quality synthetic rubber compound and RubberGard EPDM membrane that exhibits outstanding resistance of the UV radiation. More so, it can protect the roof from severe weather conditions as well as from the ozone.
The 10′ X 15′ Firestone RubberGard 60-Mil EPDM Roofing Rubber can ensure you an extended life service along with low-temperature properties. Another impressive thing about the underlayment is it includes an environmentally-aware membrane that can be recyclable for different situations. You may notice reductions in thermal temperature after using it. It can be an excellent choice for these who are searching for a biodegradable roofing solution.
As per the manufacturer claimed, the 10′ X 15′ Firestone RubberGard 60-Mil EPDM Roofing Rubber can be fully ballasted, mechanically attached, or ballasted as necessary during the installation. It can be used for a new roof, re-roof, roofing applications, and low slopes. As the material is flexible, it provides excellent versatility and also very to install. The product can be an excellent choice for DIY homeowners to work with for unusual roof shapes.
Key Features:
- High-quality synthetic rubber compound and EPDM membrane construction.
- It can be used for low slope, new, re-roof, and roofing applications.
- It can be used for unusual roof shapes.
- Easy to install with flexible material for versatility.
- Extremely durable and low life cycle cost.
- Easy to install.
- Environment-friendly and ensure low energy consumption.
- Offer longer service life.
- Perfect for a variety of applications.
- No cons found.
2. Tyvek Protec 120 Roof Underlayment – Best Multi-Purpose Roof Underlayment
Product Specification:
Brand: Tyvek
Product Dimension: 48.1 x 6.3 x 6.3 inches
Weight: 11.6 Pounds
Size: 4′ x 250′Material: Synthetic Material
The Tyvek Protec 120 Roof Underlayment is another excellent roof underlayment that you can select for a variety of multiple purposes. It is compatible with a variety of roofs, including the cedar shingles, metal roof, and asphalt shingles. Though it can be used for different types of roofs, you will get the best result when using it for the asphalt shingles. As the manufacturer advertises, you can be fully assured about the quality of the product.
The Tyvek Protec 120 Roof Underlayment is fully weatherproof, ensuring that you will get excellent performance from the product throughout the year. It includes textured, which increases overall functionality and also makes it safer to work. We didn’t notice a lot of products that arrive with such amazing features. It can be used for a variety of roofing applications, including repair, new construction, and re-roofing.
As per our research, the Tyvek Protec 120 Roof Underlayment is pretty lightweight when compared with most of the options available in the market. It includes an extra layer that can resist the water, making your house or properties entirely safe during the monsoon. The texture in the surface also makes it wrinkle-free, withstand UV exposure for three months, and also makes it easy to chalk.
Key Features:
- Compatible with cedar shingles, metal roofs, and asphalt shingles.
- It can be used for repair, new applications, and re-roofing.
- Unique embossed pattern for better grip and traction during construction.
- Resist from UV rays exposure for three months.
- Include an additional layer to resist moisture and water.
- Well-engineered and industrial-grade product.
- Easy to chalk and wrinkle-free.
- Slip-resistant coating for the user’s safety.
- Highly durable and weatherproof.
- A superior choice for the asphalt shingles.
- You may get exposed to some harmful chemicals while working.
- It can be a little hard to use for the DIY homeowner.
3. Grace Select 36 in. X 195 sq. Ft. Roll Roofing – Best for DIY home Owners
Product Specification:
Brand: Grace
Product Dimension: 41 x 9 x 8 inches
Weight: Around 50 Pounds
Size: 36 in. x 195 sq. ft.Material: Not Listed
The Grace Select 36 in. X 195 sq. Ft. Roll Roofing Underlayment is thin and lightweight that arrives with self-adhered properties that make it easier to install. Such features make it one of the best choices for DIY homeowners. Though light and thin, the roofing underlayment can offer premium-grade protection against severe climatic conditions such as rain, wind, ice. It also has a rubberized asphalt layer, which can seal around roofing nails, enabling a tight seal and additional protection.
One of the impressive things about the Grace Select Roll Roofing Underlayment is it can be used for most of the roofing materials. More so, you can also use it in a range of slopes with the highest and lowest slope design. It also has a quick foldless release paper that will not crack or dry-out, as well as slip-resistant.
The Grace Select Roll Roofing Underlayment can save you not only from the extreme weather but also from the harmful UV sun rays. It is one of the toughest underlayment solutions that can be used for almost all types of materials and roof design. If you are searching for a quality and lightweight roofing solution that can also offer you superior-grade protection, then Grace Select Roll can be an excellent choice for you.
Key Features:
- Available at 36 in. X 195 sq. Ft. dimensions.
- Quality properties to protect against different weather conditions.
- Rubberized asphalt layer with roofing nails for superior sealing.
- Lightweight, thin, and slip-resistant to install easily.
- Arrives with a quick foldless release paper to resist crack and dry out.
- Versatile roof underlayment; perfect for different applications.
- Ensure the safety of your home by defending against UV rays.
- Very easy to install, perfect for the DIY applications.
- Highly durable and suitable for long-term use.
- Some users claimed the materials used in it are very sticky.
4. Roof Protector Underlayment Roll – Best for Lightweight Applications
Brand: DuPont
Product Dimension: 42.2 x 5.8 x 5.8 inches
Weight: 21 Pounds
Size: 42″ x 286′Material: Not Listed
The Roof Protector Underlayment Roll comes from the manufacturer DuPont who is famous for manufacturing quality products. It is considered a new product in the market, but it arrives with quality properties that can make it a market dominator anytime. It is incredibly lightweight for easier installation and handling. Such properties make it a perfect pick for any DIY workers. It can also ensure 90 days of UV resistance to ensure your safety.
The Roof Protector Underlayment Roll comes from the manufacturer DuPont who is famous for manufacturing quality products. It is considered a new product in the market, but it arrives with quality properties that can make it a market dominator anytime. It is incredibly lightweight for easier installation and handling. Such properties make it a perfect pick for any DIY workers. It can also ensure 90 days of UV resistance to ensure your safety.
The Roof Protector Underlayment Roll arrives with four-layer construction that makes it extremely durable and suitable for a lot of applications. Such construction also offers you an excellent grip and ensures strength to minimize the tearing at the fastener points. The slip-resistant product can be an excellent choice for any homeowner who wants to install it from their own.
The Roof Protector Underlayment Roll arrives with ten squares in every roll. It can ensure you maximum roof coverage and efficiency while installing. As there are fewer overlaps, fasteners, and seams, there will be lower waste and lower labor costs. The DuPont Roof Protector Underlayment Roll combines superior durability along with high thermal stability to ensure robust protection in different conditions.
Key Features:
- Lightweight and thin construction for higher durability.
- Four-layer construction ensures better grip and strength.
- Arrives as 10 square at every roll for maximum coverage.
- Fewer seams, overlap, and fastener for reduced waste and labor cost.
- Super durability with higher thermal stability than roofing felt.
- Versatile construction for long-term durability.
- Easy to install for DIY homeowners.
- Arrives with better grip and slip-resistant.
- Perfect for a wide variety of conditions.
- May leak water as it is not marker waterproof.
5. MCA, Plastic String Reinforced Poly Sheeting – Best for Durable Performance
Product Specification:
Brand: MCA: Multiple Concrete Accessories
Product Dimension: 48 x 10 x 10 inches
Weight: 94 Pounds
Size: 40 Feet X 100 FeetMaterial: Transaculent
The Plastic String Reinforced Poly Sheeting is available at a reasonable price that arrives with quality properties. There is not a lot of roof underlayment product available in the markets that are available at such a low price. It includes a waterproof membrane that can ensure durable performance for a long time. One of the impressive things about the underlayment is it can prevent water leakage efficiently.
The MCA, Plastic String Reinforced Poly Sheeting, is also straightforward to use. If you are living in a calm environment, then the product will be an excellent choice for you. It can also be used for different applications apart from roofing. If you are searching for a durable, lightweight, and cost-friendly product, then it can be an excellent choice for you.
Key Features:
- Made of plastic ingredients; highly lightweight but durable.
- The waterproof membrane can protect against water leakage.
- Durable enough for temporary roofing as well as other applications.
- Transparent material; do not cause puncture normally.
- Extremely cheap.
- Lightweight and easy to install.
- Can resist water leakage.
- Not suitable for rough weather conditions.
6. Grace Ice & Water Shield Roofing Underlayment – Best for Large Roofs
Product Specification:
Brand: Grace
Product Dimension: 48 x 10 x 10 inches
Weight: 39.8 Pounds
Size: 36 in. x 75 ft. (225 sq. ft.)Material: rubberized asphalt, polyethylene film
The Grace Ice & Water Shield Roofing Underlayment is another new product in the market that arrives with quality properties to ensure you a proper performance. One of the impressive things about the product is its quality construction. The roof underlayment is made of a premier membrane composed of various waterproof materials. Such properties ensure that you can use it for a long time without any issues.
The Grace Ice & Water Shield Roofing Underlayment includes a layer of slip-resistant and coated high-density polyethylene cross-laminated film. It includes aggressive rubberized asphalt adhesive to ensure ease of use. It also arrives with a foldless release paper that ensures the highest-quality adhesive. You can easily remove the release paper and then add it to the roof deck. There are also unique split releases on-demand feature in the ripcord of the adhesive.
The Grace Ice & Water Shield Roofing Underlayment is an extremely versatile product. That means you can use it from a large variety of roofs, including the sloped roof, asphalt shingle, tile, cedar, slate, standing seam metal, etc. It is suitable for all climate and assembly conditions as per the manufacturer. The highly durable with super-tight laps can be chosen for a variety of roofing applications.
Key Features:
- Made of premier membranes composed of two waterproof materials.
- Include a layer of slip-resistant coat and HD polyethylene firm.
- Arrives with foldless release papers to ensure adhesive efficiency.
- Arrives as ripcord embedded in the adhesive for slip release on demand.
- It can be used for sloped roofs, shingles, slates, tiles, cedar, metal, etc. roofings.
- Prevent leaks caused by water and wind.
- Easy to install as slip-resistant.
- Highly durable to ensure long-term performance.
- Ensure high-quality seals around fasteners.
- Form quality watertight laps.
- A little bit costly variations.
- May is not a suitable choice for flat roofs as a permanent solution.
7. MFM Wind & Water Seal Underlayment – Best Underlayment with Sealing Properties
Product Specification:
Brand: MFM
Product Dimension: 36.33 x 8 x 8 inches
Weight: 52 Pounds
Size: Length: 67 ft., Roll Width: 36 in.Material: rubberized asphalt, polyethylene film
The MFM Wind & Water Seal Underlayment is an excellent self-adhering roof underlayment solution that is made of the non-slip polymer film. The product arrives with quality rubberized asphalt adhesive to ensure a better grip for easier installation. It can never crack or dry as remains protected by split release film that can be removed during the installation. The roll length is 67 feet, and its width is around 36 inches.
The MFM Wind & Water Seal Underlayment requires proper ventilation during the installation. That is because it is basically a vapor barrier. As per the manufacturer, the product is compatible with most of the primers and sealants available in the market. You can use the product for plywood, OSB, foam insulation, house wrap, masonry, rigid vinyl, and many more things. However, make sure that the surface is dry and clean before applying.
The MFM Wind & Water Seal Underlayment can be the perfect choice for the protection of different weather conditions. It can offer you a tight performance against the ice dams as well as from the wind-driven rain. Another impressive thing about the underlayment is it can also superiorly elastic and high elongation and allows expansion of the application’s surface. If you are searching for a secondary waterproofing material for your roof, then it can be an absolute no brainer for you.
Key Features:
- Self-adhering roof underlayment with split release film.
- Non-slip polymer film to ensure safety while installing.
- Compatible with most primers and sealants.
- Arrives with an extended ten years warranty from the manufacturer.
- Flexible, high elongation, and self-sealing around fasteners.
- Seals water and wind effectively.
- Arrives with the overlapping instructions.
- Perfect for a lot of applications.
- Best choice for secondary waterproofing.
- A little bit complex to apply.
How to Choose the Right Roof Underlayment
Selecting the right roof underlayment can be a confusing if you are a DIY homeowner. That is why you have to consider different things, such as compatibility, quality, durability, etc. and others before buying the product. However, the below guide can make it easier for you to select the right roof underlayment. We have discussed the things that you should consider before choosing the roofing underlayment.
Check the weather condition of your area
The first thing that you require to acknowledge is the weather condition of your location. Depending on the weather condition, you will need to select the right variation of the roofing underlayment. If you live in wet areas, then you must choose a product that can waterproof and prevent water leakage. If you live in extremely hot weather, then you will need to buy a roof underlayment that can reflect the sunlight to keep the environment of the house cold.
Be assured about the compatibility
There are different variations of the roof underlayment, depending on the construction and properties. They can be divided into three divisions, which are felt, rubberized, and synthetic. The felt underlayment is usually made of the organic materials and may include fiberglass reinforcement to better strength and longevity.
The felt underlayment is most suitable for steep-sloping roofs as it can help to let the water runoff quickly. They are also cheap at cost. One issue about the felt underlayment is they can become weak over time and cannot absorb the water properly. It will not be an excellent choice if you are searching for high-grade water resistance and durability.
The rubberized underlayment is made of rubber materials. They are polymer modified and include bitumen to provide rubber or plastic properties. One of the notable things about the variation is it is self-sealing, flexible, and elastic. They are mostly suitable for the high-temperature environment. They can also offer outstanding weather resistance and moisture penetration.
The synthetic is considered as the best roof underlayment as it offers better insulation and waterproof when compared with the other variations. Also, the synthetic underlayment is more breathable and enables the humidity to escape as well as resisting the water penetration. It can also protect from wind, rain, ice for an extended period. Though they cost a little bit more, they are suitable for most of the types of roofs and offer better durability.
Consider the material of your roof
Different types of roofing material suit different underlayments. As an example, for the traditional roofing, you can go for the felt underlayment. It will suit you better as it is lightweight. The best roof underlayment for a metal roof is the synthetic one. As it works as an insulator and helps excess temperature to exit, it will be an excellent choice for the high-temperature environment. Depending on your roof material, you must select the right roofing underlayment.
Check the durability of the product
The strength of the roofing underlayment is another essential thing to consider while selecting the product. As you must not invest in it within a while, you should consider this aspect seriously. Check the material used in the construction of the product to be assured about its durability. Analyzing the previous customer reviews of the product can also be an excellent way to know about its toughness in real.
Price of the product
Depending on the quality, types, and the brand name, the price of the roof underlayment can vary on a large scale. As a general rule of thumbs, the better product will cost you a larger amount, but it can ensure you better durability. On the other hand, the cheap underlayment will low in quality and may not serve you for a long time. Try to go for the best roofing underlayment available in your budget.
FAQ about Roof Underlayment
While selecting the roof underlayment, some common questions may hit your mind. Below, we will answer some of such queries.
Why I need the roof underlayment?
As we said earlier, the roof underlayment works as an extra layer of protection along with your shingles. It also helps to prevent water leakage during the rainy season. Some types of roof underlayment also help to prevent moisture and temperature along with letting go of the excess heat from the roof surface. They can also help to enhance the durability of the shingle.
Is roof underlayment waterproof?
Most types of roofing underlayment are waterproof. They can work as a water-resisting barrier before the shingle. However, there are some types of underlayment available in the markets that are not made waterproof. If you are especially searching for a watertight roof underlayment, then you should check the specifications of the product before purchasing it.
How do you put underlayment on a roof?
You can either do it from your own or take help from the professional installers. However, you may require paying a good amount of money for the roof underlayment services. Some of the manufacturers provide necessary instructions with the product for the installation. There are also tutorials and guidelines available on the internet for this purpose.
Which is better felt or synthetic underlayment?
When it comes to synthetic roof underlayment vs felt, the synthetic roof underlayment will offer you the better result. Generally, the synthetic underlayment is lightweight, insulating, and waterproof. They also allow the heat and humidity to escape from the surface to keep your room. However, they will cost you a more significant amount when compared with the felt underlayment.
How long can roof underlayment be exposed?
It depends on the variations of the underlayment. As different varieties arrive with different qualities, the lifespan of the product also varies. Usually, the synthetic roof underlayment can be left exposed for around six months to twelve months. For the felt underlayment, the period is approximately three months to six months.
We have discussed the best roof underlayment briefly above and also provided an in-depth buying guide. Now it should be easier for you to select the right product depending on your priority. You can go for any of the products as per your budget without any further thoughts.
However, if you are still in hesitation, then we will suggest you go for the Firestone RubberGard 60-Mil EPDM Roofing Rubber. You can purchase it without any further hesitation as it arrives with all the required properties. As per the previous customer of the product, there are no flaws in it.
Leave a Reply